Divorce: When One Parent Wants Private School
In Pennsylvania, decisions regarding a child’s schooling after the parents divorce depend on custody. If a judge has awarded you sole custody, you can send your child to whatever school you wish without the input of the child’s other parent. However, sole custody is rare, usually occurring only if there is a history of abuse, negligence, or inability to parent. Generally, the court awards joint custody, which requires both parents to agree on major decisions that affect your child.
If you want to send your child to a private school but your co-parent does not, you may need the help of an experienced divorce attorney to resolve the dispute. Our first step is to review your original parenting agreement approved by the court. What was in the plan? If private education was not in the written document, we may need to go to court in order to request a modification.
You may argue that the two of you had always discussed sending your children to private school eventually, but a verbal agreement is not sufficient to compel the court to change the parenting plan. We need to prove that it is in the best interests of the child and that your ex-spouse’s objections are insufficient to prevent the change in education.
We need to clarify your ex’s possible objections and find weaknesses in the arguments. Your spouse might:
- Object to the cost of private school but could afford it
- Object to that particular school but would be open to another school
- Have stated rational objections, such as distance or inconvenience for transportation – be prepared to overcome these reasonable objections with doable workarounds
- Have stated irrational objections, such as thinking the child would become nerdy; doesn’t like the uniforms; the school doesn’t have a champion sports team; your ex knew someone who went to that school and hates that person – any irrational comments of this nature can demonstrate unreasonable opposition
We also need to be prepared with overwhelming reasons to show that the school change would be in the best interests of the child:
- The new school offers a superior education
- Your child is being bullied or has had negative experiences at their current school and needs to change schools
- The new school would be in better alignment with the values you are teaching your child
- Your child has good friends in that school
- The private school offers stronger academics or opportunities in the particular interests of the child
- This private school is a better fit than other schools
Pennsylvania law does not require parents to pay for private education. However, if the court determines that the parents have the ability to pay for private education and it is in the best interests of the child, a divorce modification may be awarded.
At Karen Ann Ulmer P.C., Attorneys at Law, we know that situations change over time, especially regarding parenting, and modifications are sometimes necessary. Request a confidential consultation today at one of our Southeast PA offices by calling (866) 349-4721 so we can get started right away. Your child deserves to attend a school where he or she will truly thrive. We will work with you to make that happen.




